Savage Garden [Complete] Review

Despite positive initial impressions, the dark ambience and uniquely dark tone can only take you so far with an ending that drops out of nowhere like a lead balloon. Disappointment? Yes. Raging fangirls? I count myself in their numbers. Grab your torch and pitchfork, because if you have stuck with this manhwa since the beginning, you probably have a bone to pick with Lee Hyeon-Sook considering the subpar ending that was delivered. But watch your step, there are plot holes everywhere.

With a plot that does not deliver, Savage Garden strangely starts off with some promise. Initially we are introduced, just as the synposis describes, to a school that, despite housing the well-to-do, has incredibly harsh hierarchy. Gabriel enters, impersonating her deceased childhood friend, and taking on the persona of “Jeremy.” Led by the promise of riches, “Jeremy” tries to lay low without invoking the wrath of some the more prominent – and cruel – noblemen that she dorms with.

As you can well predict, she inevitably lands herself in trouble and becomes tangled up with two brothers. The premise is a little misleading, however, because it eventually becomes a derailed train that crashes and burns.

In regards to the aforementioned plot holes, the author blatantly omits a lot of information in the latter half of the story, as we are suddenly thrust into the ending without any preparation. There is no leading up to it, no real resolutions in terms of the climax of the story. It just lands in our lap, incomplete and ill-conceived. My suspicions are that the author came to an impasse, with no motivation left for continuing, and decided to end prematurely. As a result, many questions were left unanswered and the ending left you wondering if you were still reading the same series.

The characters, who are both interesting and intriguing, are vaguely explored through the story. Once again, this is where the potential really shined through but inevitably fell short. Gabriel suddenly became the traditional damsel-in-distress whereas she had been a heroine with some measure of self-sufficiently in the beginning. Her desire to reclaim her pride from her status of fallen nobility, as a driving force, is far more realistic than the shallow reasons seen in other gender benders.

But, just as with Gabriel, the other characters either dropped out of the picture or were poorly utilized approaching the ending. Rather than feeling like real people, they felt like a means to an end – as though, rather than seeing through the story with the characters she had built and developed, the author used them as a tool to bring things to a close without considering the quality she was losing in doing so.

As for the art, it seems a bit more detailed and a step up from her previous works, which is definitely a positive. Among manhwa, her art stands out as well-proportioned and, in simple terms, very “pretty.” Even compared to many manga, Lee Hyeon-Sook has a very unique style that captivates. There is plenty of good eye candy.

So what is Savage Garden ultimately? A manhwa that initially stands out amongst its fellow creations but inevitably falls short as an underwhelming read with a disappointing ending. As much as it dispels age-old shoujo cliches, it wallows in its own depressing undertones and flickers out like an unnoticed flame.

Rating: 6/10


This entry was posted in Shoujo and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Savage Garden [Complete] Review

  1. Anonymous says:

    I agree with your review. The manhwa starts out strong…and suddenly depreciates in story value, post-climactic expression and characters.

  2. Fosco says:

    I am here with you, the ending was so absurd that it hurt to read it, for a story that started with such promise it did fail to deliver and leaves us resonating with dissatisfaction and a certain amount of frustration. 7/10 for the beginning and 2/10 for the ending.

  3. Mai Nguyen says:

    Well, I do have to admit that the story was pretty rushed and that the author could have spent more time on character development and extended the story a couple volumes more. But I think that what the author did with the manwha starting out strong and then Jeremy (Gabriel) slowly deteriorating is what she did right due to being in that type of environment. Almost anyone being placed in that kind of horrible and savage environment would eventually crumble down and become psychologically unstable. Look what happened to the kids in Lord of the Flies by William Golding. They all went bonkers after they couldn’t handle their situation anymore. So its not surprising to see a strong character like Gabriel breaking down since it is inevitable to happen to anyone.

    But the only things I have to complain about is: WHERE THE FUCKIN’ HELL DID THAT COME FROM!? That was just so random and out of the blue for Euan Kensinton to be shot by some random guy! WHAT THE HELL!!! I also wanted to know what happened to Gabriel after she boarded the ship and also what happened to the other characters. Its like the author completely forgot that she had other players in her play! Yea, the ending was kinda weird and I wanted to know what happened to Angela? Did she and Ray get married or not?

  4. ironf51 says:

    will they continue writing savage garden and will there be a next capter

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s